Gold Coin vs ETF: Where should you invest for maximum returns?
Whether you are looking at gold as a hedge against inflation or a long-term wealth builder, the method of "holding" that gold changes your final take-home profit. While physical gold offers a sense of security, digital alternatives like Gold ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds) are often praised for their efficiency.
But which one actually puts more money in your pocket? Using a fixed investment of ₹1,00,000, let's break down three specific mathematical scenarios to see who wins the ROI battle.
The Math Behind the Friction
Before looking at the growth, we must account for the "leakage" in both assets.
Gold Coin Leakage
You lose money immediately at the shop.
- Entry Cost: 4% Making Charges + 3% GST (Total ~7.1% immediate loss).
- Exit Cost: A 2% "spread" or difference in the selling price compared to the market rate.
Gold ETF Leakage
You lose money slowly over time.
- Annual Drag: An average of 0.85% per year (Expense Ratio + Tracking Error).
Scenario 1: The Medium-Term Sprint (5 Years)
Here is the detailed comparison for a 5-year investment period using your new buying rates.
a. Gold Coin Investment (5 Years)
Purchase Phase:
Gold Rate: ₹39,108.00 (31 Dec 2019)
Making Charge (4%): ₹1,564.32
GST (3% on total): ₹1,220.17
Effective Buying Price: ₹41,892.49
Grams purchased with ₹1,00,000: 2.3871 grams
Selling Phase:
Market Selling Rate: ₹1,35,447.00 (31 Dec 2025)
Effective Selling Price (98%): ₹1,32,738.06
Maturity Value: 2.3871 grams × 132,738.06 = ₹3,16,854
b. Gold ETF Investment (5 Years) (GOLDBEES)
Purchase Phase:
Buying NAV: 34.45 (31 Dec 2019)
Units purchased: 1,00,000 / 34.45 = 2902.76 units
Selling Phase:
Selling NAV: 110.11 (31 Dec 2025)
Maturity Value: 2902.76 units × 110.11 = ₹3,19,623
3. Comparison of Returns (5 Years)
| Feature | Gold Coin | Gold ETF |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Investment | ₹1,00,000 | ₹1,00,000 |
| Maturity Value | ₹3,16,854 | ₹3,19,623 |
| Net Profit | ₹2,16,854 | ₹2,19,623 |
| Absolute Return | 216.85% | 219.62% |
| CAGR (Annualized) | 25.94% | 26.16% |
In this 5-year scenario, the Gold ETF gives a better return by approximately ₹2,769.
Based on the prices you provided (39,108 → 135,447), the physical gold price grew at 28.2% annually. However, your ETF NAVs (34.45 → 110.11) grew at only 26.1%. This indicates the ETF was lagging the actual gold price by about 2% per year in this specific period (higher than the standard 0.5-1%). Even with this significant lag, the ETF still won because the 5-year duration wasn't long enough for that drag to outweigh the coin's high making charges.
Scenario 2: The Historical High-Growth Era (10 Years)
To compare the net returns of a Gold Coin versus a Gold ETF based on your specific figures, we need to account for the "friction" (charges and taxes) for the coin and the NAV growth for the ETF.
a. Gold Coin Investment Calculation
Purchase Phase:
Gold Rate: ₹24,931.00 (Dec 2015)
Making Charge (4%): ₹997.24
Sub-total: ₹25,928.24
GST (3% on total): ₹777.85
Effective Buying Price (per gram): ₹26,706.09
Grams purchased with ₹1,00,000: 3.7445 grams
Selling Phase (After 10 Years):
Market Selling Rate: ₹1,35,447.00 (31 Dec 2025)
Selling Price after 2% difference: 135,447 × 0.98 = ₹1,32,738.06
Total Maturity Value: 3.7445 grams × 132,738.06 = ₹4,97,033
b. Gold ETF Investment Calculation
Purchase Phase:
Buying NAV: 22.79 (31 Dec 2015)
Units purchased with ₹1,00,000: 1,00,000 / 22.79 = 4387.89 units
Selling Phase (After 10 Years):
Selling NAV: 110.11 (31 Dec 2025)
Total Maturity Value: 4387.89 units × 110.11 = ₹4,83,151
c. Detailed Comparison of Returns
| Feature | Gold Coin | Gold ETF |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Investment | ₹1,00,000 | ₹1,00,000 |
| Maturity Value | ₹4,97,033 | ₹4,83,151 |
| Net Profit | ₹3,97,033 | ₹3,83,151 |
| Absolute Return | 397.03% | 383.15% |
| CAGR (Annualized) | 17.39% | 17.06% |
Summary & Conclusion
In this specific scenario, the Gold Coin gives a better net return by approximately ₹13,882.
Why did the Coin win?
- Cost of Friction vs. Expense Ratio: The total one-time friction for the coin (Making + GST + Selling Spread) amounted to roughly 9.1% of the value.
- ETF Drag: In this case, the GoldBees ETF's NAV grew by 4.83x, while the raw gold price grew by 5.43x. This implies an annual "drag" (expense ratio + tracking error) of about 1.37%. Over 10 years, this compounded drag (approx. 12.8%) exceeded the one-time 9.1% cost of the physical coin.
Why did the result flip?
- Short/Medium Term (5 Years): The ETF (as seen in your first example) wins because the heavy upfront "entry load" of the physical coin (Making Charges + GST ≈ 7.1%) hits your capital immediately. Even though the ETF has annual charges, over just 5 years, they add up to less than the one-time hit you took on the coin.
- Long Term (10+ Years): The Coin wins because you pay the entry cost only once. Over a long period, the small annual fees of the ETF eventually compound into a larger amount than the one-time making charge of the coin.
- Storage & Insurance: The calculation for the Gold Coin assumes zero cost for storage (bank locker) and insurance. If you factor in ₹2,000–₹3,000 annual locker rent, the ETF would likely become the more profitable option.
- Liquidity: The ETF can be sold instantly on the stock exchange, whereas selling a physical coin at the exact "market rate - 2%" might require visiting specific jewelers.
- Purity Risk: The ETF guarantees 24k purity, while physical gold requires verification.
Scenario 3: The "Steady Growth" Projection (10% CAGR)
Lets assume you buy gold of worth 1 Lakh at the rate of 1.5 Lakhs which If we assume a steady 10% annual growth for gold moving forward, here is the projected outcome for 5-year and 10-year horizons.
The Scenario Assumptions
- Investment: ₹1,00,000
- Physical Gold Growth: 10% CAGR (Annual Growth)
- ETF Growth: 9.15% CAGR (Assumed 0.85% lag, which is the average of your 0.7%–1% range)
- Coin Costs: Buying: 4% Making + 3% GST. Selling: 2% deduction from market rate.
1. 5-Year Comparison
In the medium term, the ETF wins because the physical coin's high "entry cost" (Making + GST) hasn't had enough time to be amortized, whereas the ETF's annual "lag" hasn't compounded enough to hurt the returns.
| Feature | Gold Coin (Physical) | Gold ETF (Digital) |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Investment | ₹1,00,000 | ₹1,00,000 |
| Gold Worth Bought | ₹93,353 (After 7.1% entry cost) |
₹1,00,000 (100% invested) |
| Value After 5 Years | ₹1,50,346 (Grows @ 10%) | ₹1,54,924 (Grows @ 9.15%) |
| Selling Deduction | -₹3,007 (2% margin) | ₹0 |
| Final Pocket Value | ₹1,47,339 | ₹1,54,924 |
| Net Profit | ₹47,339 | ₹54,924 |
| Winner | ETF (by ~₹7,585) |
2. 10-Year Comparison
Over the long term, the race tightens significantly. The "friction" of the coin is fixed at the start, but the "drag" of the ETF (0.85% per year) keeps eating into the returns every single year.
| Feature | Gold Coin (Physical) | Gold ETF (Digital) |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Investment | ₹1,00,000 | ₹1,00,000 |
| Gold Worth Bought | ₹93,353 | ₹1,00,000 |
| Value After 10 Years | ₹2,42,134 (Grows @ 10%) | ₹2,40,014 (Grows @ 9.15%) |
| Selling Deduction | -₹4,843 (2% margin) | ₹0 |
| Final Pocket Value | ₹2,37,291 | ₹2,40,014 |
| Net Profit | ₹1,37,291 | ₹1,40,014 |
| Winner | ETF (by ~₹2,723) |
Critical "Tipping Point" Analysis
The 10-year result is extremely close. The winner depends entirely on exactly how much the ETF lags behind the actual gold price (Tracking Error + Expense Ratio).
- If ETF lags by 0.85% (Average): ETF Wins (as shown above, by ₹2,700).
- If ETF lags by 1.0% (Worst Case): Coin Wins.
Calculation: ETF return drops to ₹2,36,736, while Coin remains at ₹2,37,291. The Coin would win by approx. ₹555.
Final Verdict: Which Should You Choose?
Choose Gold ETFs if:
- Your horizon is < 10 years: As shown in Scenario 1 and 3, the ETF's lower entry cost makes it more profitable in the short-to-medium term.
- You value liquidity: You can sell ETFs in seconds on the stock market.
- Safety is a concern: You don't need a bank locker (which can cost ₹2,000–₹5,000/year, further eating into physical gold returns).
Choose Gold Coins if:
- You are a "Forever" Holder: If you plan to keep the gold for 15–20 years or pass it down as an heirloom, the one-time making charge becomes negligible compared to the decades of annual fees an ETF would charge.
- You want a tangible asset: In extreme economic crises, physical gold in your hand has zero counterparty risk (unlike a digital fund).
Join the conversation